Self-Compassion in ADHD: A Critical Target for Coaches and Therapists

Eliza Barach
Apr 8
4 min read

When ADHD Support Needs More Than Just Strategy

"I know what I need to do, but I just can't make myself do it. And then I hate myself for failing...again."

As an ADHD coach or therapist, you've likely heard this refrain many times. Your clients arrive carrying not just executive function challenges, but years of self-criticism, shame, and negative self-perception built on perceived failures and unmet expectations.

While we typically focus on a wide array of things, such as goal setting, organizational strategies and executive function skills, recent research suggests we may be undervaluing a fundamental element that significantly impacts outcomes: self-compassion.

The Research: Self-Compassion, ADHD, and Mental Health

A 2022 study by Beaton, Sirois, and Milne examined the relationship between ADHD, self-compassion, and mental health outcomes, offering valuable insights for anyone working with ADHD clients.

What the Research Revealed

The researchers found that adults with ADHD consistently show lower levels of self-compassion compared to neurotypical adults. More importantly, these lower self-compassion levels partially explain:

Higher rates of depression, anxiety, and stress
Lower levels of psychological, emotional, and social well-being

Using structural equation modeling (SEM), the researchers revealed that self-compassion acts as a mediator between ADHD diagnosis and mental health outcomes. Even when controlling for gender and comorbidities, the data showed a clear pattern:

ADHD → Lower Self-Compassion → Poorer Mental Health.

Why Self-Compassion Matters for ADHD Practitioners

As professionals supporting people with ADHD, we tend to concentrate on setting goals/visions, building executive function skills, implementing systems, and creating environmental accommodations. These approaches remain essential, but this research suggests they're only part of the picture.

When your clients with ADHD learn to respond to their struggles with kindness rather than harsh self-judgment, several shifts occur:

The stress response decreases, allowing better access to executive functions
Recovery from setbacks happens more quickly
Internal motivation becomes more sustainable
Shame spirals occur less frequently

These benefits directly support the practical strategies and skills we typically focus on in ADHD treatment.

Practical Applications: Integrating Self-Compassion Into Your ADHD Practice

Assessment: Measuring Self-Compassion Levels

Consider assessing your client's baseline self-compassion as part of your intake process or as an intervention later down the line. The Self-Compassion Scale (SCS) developed by Dr. Kristin Neff measures six components:

Self-Kindness vs. Self-Judgment
Common Humanity vs. Isolation
Mindfulness vs. Over-identification

The 26-item scale uses a 5-point rating system, with scores between 1.0-2.49 considered low, 2.5-3.5 moderate, and 3.51-5.0 high.

Reframing Self-Compassion for ADHD Clients

Many ADHD clients misinterpret self-compassion as self-pity or making excuses. Here's how you might explain it:

"Self-compassion isn't about letting yourself off the hook; it's about creating a supportive internal environment that makes growth possible. Think of it as creating the fundamental conditions for your brain to learn and adapt."

Help clients understand that self-compassion involves:

Treating oneself with the same kindness they would offer a friend
Recognizing that imperfection is part of the shared human experience

Coaching Techniques: Self-Compassion Exercises for ADHD Challenges

The Three-Part Compassionate Response

When clients report ADHD-related difficulties, guide them through this process:

Mindful Awareness: "What happened? What emotions and thoughts came up?"
Explore the ADHD Connection: "What aspects of your ADHD might be involved? How might others with ADHD relate to this?"
Self-Kindness: "What would you say to a friend with ADHD who had this same experience? What’s preventing you from offering yourself that same understanding?"

Reframing "Failures" as Data & Get Curious

Help clients shift from self-criticism to learning when and why strategies don't work: "Instead of 'I failed again,' try 'This strategy doesn't match my brain's needs. What can I do differently that will work with my brain?'" This maintains accountability while removing shame that blocks progress.

Beyond Productivity: Supporting the Whole Person with ADHD

This research reminds us that our goal is not only to help ADHD clients be more “productive” or build their EF skills, but it's also to support their overall well-being and quality of life. After all, what value do symptom improvements hold if they don't translate to an enhanced quality of life?

By incorporating self-compassion alongside traditional ADHD interventions, we create space for clients to:

Recover from setbacks without spiraling into shame
Take risks with new strategies without fear of harsh self-judgment
Build motivation based on self-care rather than self-criticism
Navigate ADHD challenges with resilience and emotional balance

Practitioner Reflection Questions

How do you currently address self-criticism in your ADHD clients?
In what ways might your approach unintentionally reinforce performance-based self-worth?
What self-compassion practices could you integrate into your next client session?
How might you assess whether your client's self-compassion is increasing over time?
What barriers might your ADHD clients face in developing self-compassion, and how could you help them overcome these?

Join Our ADHD Practitioners Community

Want to deepen your understanding of ADHD coaching and hone your coaching skills? Join the ADHD Practitioners Community, where I provide exclusive insights, research breakdowns, and a space for ADHD professionals to connect, collaborate, and refine their approach. Click here to sign up!

Want more research-backed ADHD insights?

Subscribe to my newsletter, Chaos Managed, where I break down the latest ADHD research into actionable strategies for coaches, therapists, and professionals who support ADHD clients. Click here to join!

The Science Behind This Post

Beaton, D. M., Sirois, F. M., & Milne, E. (2022). The role of self‐compassion in the mental health of adults with ADHD. Journal of Clinical Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.23354

Neff, K. D. (2003). Development and validation of a scale to measure self-compassion. Self and Identity, 2, 223-250.

Disclaimer

Remember: This is general information, not medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making any decisions regarding ADHD treatment or coaching approaches.