top of page
Search

Why Your ADHD Brain Chooses Productive Procrastination (And How to Work With It)

Ever find yourself cleaning your entire house instead of starting that important project? Well, yes that's often an ADHD thing.. Here's the science behind productive procrastination and practical strategies for ADHD brains.


I wasn't planning on writing this post today. In fact, I told myself I'd be focusing entirely on writing my book about goal-setting and ADHD. But here I am, typing away at my computer instead of working on my book outline.

We can thank productive procrastination for that—and it turns out, there's some neuroscience behind why this happens, especially for those of us with ADHD.


What Is Productive Procrastination?

Productive procrastination occurs when you avoid one important task by completing another, more (seemingly) manageable task instead. You're still being productive and getting things done, but perhaps not in the direction you originally intended.


The Neuroscience Behind Why We Productively Procrastinate


Your Brain's Cost-Benefit Analysis

Our brains constantly perform cost-benefit analyses, scanning for the "right fit" between task demands and our current resources. When a task feels too big, too ambiguous, or too challenging, your brain essentially responds: "Nope! Too expensive for uncertain reward!"

This response makes evolutionary sense. It's metabolically expensive to allocate energy and attention to any given task, and our brains prioritize efficiency and conservation. When faced with something overwhelming or unclear, your brain:

  1. Senses risk in the uncertain task

  2. Searches for alternatives (hello, distractibility!)

  3. Redirects resources toward something with more guaranteed returns

Research by Aston-Jones & Cohen (2005) and Mittner et al. (2016) supports this understanding of how our brains seek tasks where success feels achievable.


Why ADHD Brains Experience This More Intensely

For those with ADHD, this redirection happens more quickly due to emotional dysregulation and lower frustration tolerance (Seymour et al., 2019). At the first hint of overwhelm, our brain's "discomfort alarm" triggers more intensely than neurotypical brains, sending us searching for alternatives.

This explains why I found myself creating this productive procrastination draft instead of my book outline:

  • This writing felt small, familiar, and achievable

  • The book seemed huge, under-developed, and time-consuming

My ADHD brain thought it knew which option offered a higher likelihood of success and satisfaction.



The Insidious Culprit: Ambiguity and Uncertainty

For ADHD brains, ambiguity is often the insidious seed behind procrastination. Uncertainty creates discomfort, and our brains are wired to move away from discomfort as quickly as possible.

Getting curious about this process can be enlightening. What's actually behind that discomfort?

  • Fear of failure?

  • Unclear expectations?

  • The overwhelming size of the task?

  • Perfectionist tendencies?

Understanding your specific triggers is the first step toward working with your brain instead of against it.

Practical Strategies for Managing Productive Procrastination



Strategy 1: Reverse-Engineer Your Procrastination Patterns

Next time you catch yourself productively procrastinating, pause and ask:


"What makes this current task feel easier or more rewarding than the one I'm avoiding?"


Use those insights to reshape your avoided task. Common patterns include:

  • Clear endpoints: If you're drawn to tasks with obvious completion points, create clearer milestones for your avoided task

  • Immediate feedback: If you prefer tasks with quick results, build in progress markers

  • Familiar territory: If you gravitate toward known tasks, identify the familiar elements within your challenging project


Strategy 2: Create "Stupidly Small" Starting Points

Breaking down tasks isn't just productivity advice—it's neuroscience-backed strategy. The equation is simple:


Smaller chunks = Clearer path = Increased perceived competence = Brain says "Yes!"

Don't just break down the task—make it so small it feels almost ridiculous:

  • Can you write just one sentence of that report?

  • Can you work for exactly 5 minutes?

  • Can you simply open the relevant document?

Make it so small your brain literally cannot object.


Strategy 3: Embrace Strategic Productive Procrastination

Sometimes productive procrastination leads to incredible outcomes (like this blog post!). Other times, it enables avoidance of genuinely important goals. The key is learning to distinguish between the two.

Ask yourself:

  • Is this productive procrastination serving me right now?

  • What am I avoiding, and why?

  • How can I honor both my brain's need for achievable wins AND my larger goals?


For Mental Health Professionals: Working With Productive Procrastination

When clients express frustration about doing "everything but the thing," start with curiosity rather than correction. Help them reverse-engineer what makes their productive procrastination tasks feel appealing.


Key questions to explore:

  • "What specific outcome felt achievable in the thing you did complete?"

  • "Where does your avoided task feel fuzzy or overwhelming?"

  • "How can we break this down into steps so small there's literally no reason you couldn't do them?"


Use these insights to reframe or re-sequence their original goals.


The Bottom Line: Working With Your ADHD Brain

There’s a good reason your brain engages in productive procrastination — it's your brain trying to be efficient with limited resources. By understanding the neuroscience behind this pattern and implementing brain-friendly strategies, you can work with your natural tendencies rather than fighting against them.


Remember: reducing procrastination is often about making tasks feel within reach. If something feels doable, you're far more likely to engage. If it feels overwhelming or ambiguous, your brain will redirect toward something more manageable.


Sometimes that redirection leads to wonderful, unexpected outcomes. Sometimes it means important projects sit untouched. The goal isn't to eliminate productive procrastination entirely, but instead to become more intentional about when and how it serves you.



Taking Action

Need ADHD-friendly support for productivity?


As a cognitive psychologist and certified ADHD coach specializing in high-performing professionals with ADHD, I offer evidence-based strategies through my 1:1 Coaching services and my FOCUS Forward action & accountability group coaching program.


I also provide supervision for other ADHD coaches and training for clinicians to make their interventions more ADHD-friendly.


From Chaos Managed

This article first appeared in my Chaos Managed newsletter. Subscribe to receive the full science reference list for these topics, as well as ADHD research updates and science-backed strategies from Dr. Eliza.






This information is for educational purposes and not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always

consult qualified healthcare professionals for ADHD-related concerns.



References

Aston-Jones, G., & Cohen, J. D. (2005). An integrative theory of locus coeruleus-norepinephrine function: Adaptive gain and optimal performance. Annual Review of Neuroscience, 28, 403–450.


Mittner, M., Hawkins, G. E., Boekel, W., & Forstmann, B. U. (2016). A Neural Model of Mind Wandering. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 20, 570–578.


Seymour, K. E., Macatee, R., & Chronis-Tuscano, A. (2019). Frustration Tolerance in Youth With ADHD. Journal of Attention Disorders, 23(11), 1229–1239.

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page